Which Is The Best Mattress Topper? Cheap + Luxury Picks

Which is the best type of mattress topper?

Before I give my opinion on the best mattress topper, I’ll give an explanation of the four main types of mattress topper:

Natural fibre mattress toppers

These are made from wool, feathers, duck down or goose down. Duck down and goose down is good for keeping cool and is super soft, but isn’t good for allergies unless it is specially treated and sealed. Wool is better for allergies but isn’t quite as soft as goose or duck down. Prices range from about £50 to £300. 


Synthetic mattress toppers 

These are made from polyester. They are often called things like ‘microfibre’ toppers. Prices start from about £20.


Memory foam mattress toppers (also called visco elastic)

Memory foam moulds around you so some people don’t like the sinking feeling and it can also make you feel hot. The price depends on how thick it is. Cheap memory foam toppers start at about £30.


Latex mattress toppers

These last for ages and are made from natural materials (rubber). They are expensive though (prices from about £100 upwards). 


Which is best? Most people agree that natural fibres are better than synthetic fibre mattress toppers. 

Memory foam v natural fibres is a personal preference, it depends whether you like the feel of memory foam.

Latex is a posh alternative and, but it’s not to everyone’s taste.

Researchers in China attempted to take an academic look at the question of mattress toppers in a study which was published in 2020 by Yu-Chi, Chih-Yun and Mao-Jiun. They searched for the best ‘combination of thickness and hardness’, specifically for people who sleep on their back. 

After looking at things such as ‘body pressure and temperature distribution’ they recommended that a mattress topper which is 30mm is ideal and that it should be ‘a soft topper’.


What’s the best mattress topper made from microfibre synthetic materials?​

If you’re on a tight budget or just want something cheap for a guest bed then here are a couple of decent synthetic mattress toppers:

​1. Silentnight Airmax Mattress Topper – £79 (king size)

Silentnight is probably the best known brand in the UK mattress market. This cheap mattress topper is polyester, but it gets great reviews and it is machine washable. As an overall brand, Silentnight scores well with customers, averaging 4.1/5 on TrustPilot when we checked. This particular mattress topper scores 4.4/5 from 12,000+ reviews, at the time of writing.

Pros: big name brand, low price, thousands of positive reviews, machine washable, available in two depths and four sizes

Cons: synthetic materials are less breathable

Silentnight airmax mattress topper
This topper scores 4.4/5 after thousands of reviews

[affcoups id=”3558″]


2. Sealy Select Response Mattress Topper – £35 (king size)

This cheap mattress topper from Sealy has a microfiber cover (which just means it is very finely woven) and it has something called ‘DuPont silk like fibres’. Essentially, it is a synthetic fibre but the manufacturers say it has ‘all the legendary smoothness of silk’. That might be pushing it but it gets good reviews and it’s hypoallergenic. Sealy claims to be the world’s biggest bed brand.

Pros: available in four sizes, huge bedding brand, good value, hypoallergenic

Cons: synthetic material, relatively thin

Sealy select response mattress topper

Sealy is the world’s biggest bed brand. They offer this good value synthetic topper.

[affcoups id=”3560″]


What’s the best memory foam mattress topper?

There are loads of memory foam mattress toppers to choose from, but here are three to consider:

1. Panda Mattress Topper – £159 (king size)

​The Panda Mattress Topper is worth a look as it comes with a 30 night home trial period. If you don’t like it, they’ll collect it for free and give you a refund (see the Ts and Cs). Home trials are quite common with mattresses but less so with toppers.

“But is it any good?” I hear you cry.

At the time of writing, reviews on TrustPilot average 4.8/5 after 400+ reviews whilst it scores about 4.8/5 from 1000+ reviews on the Panda website. 

Some people find memory foam makes them a bit hot in bed. However, this one aims to keep you cool by mixing the memory foam with a gel. The cover is made from bamboo which is ‘naturally antibacterial’ and ‘highly breathable’ according to the official blurb. It is 5cm thick, which is pretty decent when compared to some cheap mattress toppers.

Pros: the trial period is unusual with a mattress topper and the product gets very positive reviews. Memory foam is very good at spreading out your weight on a mattress topper.

Cons: it’s more expensive than some toppers and it is made from mostly synthetic materials.

Panda mattress topper
This Panda topper comes with a 30 day home trial

[affcoups id=”3567″]


​2. Silentnight Impress Memory Foam Mattress Topper – £76 to £129 (king size)

Silentnight is a big brand and they offer this well-reviewed memory foam topper in a couple of thicknesses. The 2.5cm version is about £76, the 5cm version is £109 and the 7cm version is £129. Personally, I’d get the deeper one if you can afford it.

Memory foam offers consistent support. Some people don’t like the sinking feel, whilst others say memory foam smells a bit at first (though that does tend to go away). It’s had 2800+ customer reviews and scores 4.3/5 at the time of typing.

Pros: memory foam does a good job of spreading out weight, choice of thickness levels and sizes, lots of positive reviews, popular brand

Cons: some find memory foam makes them feel too warm, ‘offgassing’ is common from new foam

Silentnight Impress memory foam mattress topper
This Silentnight topper comes in two different thicknesses – and gets strong reviews

[affcoups id=”3562″]


3. Tempur Mattress Topper 7 – £1099 (king size)

Hang on a minute, £1049 for a mattress topper? Bear with me a second, it’s better value than you might think.

Tempur is the world’s most famous luxury memory-foam type brand. They helped develop NASA technology into mattresses and are still the biggest name in the market. You’d usually pay £2000+ for a Tempur mattress, but you can get a topper for half that (or there’s a thinner version which is a bit cheaper).

The topper comes with a 10 year guarantee and a 100 night trial, which is unusual for a mattress topper. The cover is also washable at 60 degrees.

Pros: original memory foam brand with decades of development and manufacturing, good choice of sizes, 10 year guarantee, 100 night trial and washable cover. There are also lots of positive reviews.

Cons: several times more expensive than other memory foam brands

Tempur mattress topper
Tempur is probably the world’s most famous memory foam brand

[affcoups id=”3570″]


What’s the best mattress topper made from natural materials?

We’ve picked out a natural fibre mattress toppers which gets positive reviews and offer good value. Prices correct at time of writing.


1. John Lewis Natural Collection Pure Cotton Quilted Mattress Enhancer – £95 (king size) 

This pure cotton mattress topper from John Lewis is naturally breathable and good for hot or cold sleepers due to cotton being good for regulating temperature.

The topper is machine washable and can be tumble dried on a low temperature. It comes with a 2 year guarantee and gets 4.4/5 from over 100 reviews.

Pros: John Lewis & Partners reputation for quality, natural materials are breathable, machine washable, good reviews

​Cons: Fairly expensive

John Lewis pure cotton best mattress topper
A natural topper like this one is breathable and comfy

[affcoups id=”3572″]


Which are the best latex mattress toppers?

​There aren’t all that many latex mattress toppers on the market but here are a couple worth a look:


1. Latex Plus by Yanis 8cm Latex Mattress Topper – £387 (king size, other sizes available)

This mattress topper by Yanis gets very good reviews.

It’s made from natural latex which is good for allergies and doesn’t have quite the same sinking feeling as memory foam. It’s also a ‘natural’ material as it comes from rubber trees, whereas memory foam and microfibre mattress toppers are manmade.

This version is 8cm thick. 

Pros: natural material, consistent support, keeps you cooler than memory foam

Cons: costs as much as some new mattresses

Latex plus by Yanis 8cm
Latex is a natural and sustainable material which can offer good support on a mattress

[affcoups id=”3577″]


2. Latex Plus by Yanis 5cm Mattress Topper – £279 (king size)

OK, so this one’s pretty much the same as the Yanis latex topper above, it’s just a bit thinner and a bit cheaper. As a general rule, you will feel the benefit of a deeper mattress topper if you are heavier than average.

Latex plus by Yanis 5cm

This latex topper is a thinner and cheaper version

[affcoups id=”3584″]


Which retailers are best for buying best mattress toppers?


Why should I buy a mattress topper?

There are two advantages to buying a topper to sit on top of your mattress.

  • Hygiene – toppers collect all the sweat, grotty bacteria and other unpleasantness which would otherwise end up on the mattress (best not to think about such things when you stay in a hotel…). As a result, you can just replace the topper and keep the mattress going for a few more years. Some mattress toppers have covers which can be removed and washed.
  • Comfort – you won’t notice a lot of difference with a cheap topper, but more expensive toppers add a decent layer of comfort. It’s a bit like putting a new carpet down – it won’t cover up holes in the floorboards and you won’t notice much improvement if you get the cheap stuff they use in schools…

Does it matter what my mattress underneath is made from?

Generally, people get a mattress topper which matches the material of the mattress. So, if you’ve got a memory foam mattress you’ll get a topper which is also memory foam. However, there’s nothing to say you can’t live life on the edge and use a memory foam topper on a pocket sprung mattress. In fact, I’ve done exactly that on our spare bed as it was a bit too firm.

Promise you won’t tell anyone.


​What’s the advantage of an expensive mattress topper?

A cheap mattress topper made from polyester is perfectly adequate but a feather and down topper is better if you are inclined to get too hot in bed (ooer missus). 

Memory foam and latex are good if you have problems with allergies. There’s also an argument that memory foam and latex offer good all over support in a mattress. If it’s a thick enough topper, I don’t see why you can’t apply the same argument.


What’s the difference between a mattress pad and a mattress topper?

A topper is thicker than a mattress pad.
 
I can waffle on for a while about the history of bedding or the 94 types of mattress pads if you like, but that’s the gist of it. Perhaps I should draw a diagram of someone lying on their side to help illustrate it?