Best mattresses beginners' guide
So, which is the best brand of mattress?If money is no object, then I’d start by looking at mattress brands which have won big awards recently:
Other long-established names at the luxury end of the UK's mattress market are:
All prices are for king size mattresses, doubles are cheaper. |
If your dog looks this miserable you need a new mattress (or a new dog)
|
OK, well I’ve not got a budget of £2000 for a mattress. Which is the best mattress on a mid-range budget?
Several mid-range mattresses made it into our top 10 mattresses guide, because of a mix of expert awards, customer reviews and specification:
- Leesa Mattress (£750 memory foam mattress) - use discount code THEBESTMATTRESSGUIDE for £100 off
- Casper Hybrid Mattress (£700 'hybrid' memory foam mattress)
- Silentnight 3 Zone Memory Foam (£200 memory foam mattress)
- Dormeo Memory Plus (£250 memory foam mattress)
- Silentnight Classic 1200 pocket deluxe (£400 pocket spring mattress)
- Silentnight 2000 (£500 pocket spring mattress)
- John Lewis & Partners Natural Collection Leckford Linen' (£850 pocket spring mattress)
- Sealy Teramo 1400 (also known as Sealy Nostromo 1400) (£750 pocket spring mattress)
Which mid-price and cheap mattresses get the best customer reviews?
Another option is to just go based on customer reviews. I personally like Amazon reviews as there are often dozens to read, rather than just one or two.
Here are the top 10 rated mattresses on Amazon with at least 10 reviews, at the time of searching (October 2018). From highest rated down:
Prices are for King Size mattresses. We just searched for mattresses sold direct by Amazon rather than Marketplace sellers.
My best value picks from the top Amazon mattresses is the Happy Beds 3000 pocket spring aloe vera mattress which is £370 or for a cheap memory foam mattress I'd go for the Happy Beds Ocean Gel which is about £200
Both have specifications similar to mattresses for twice that price from better known brands. Both get great reviews, although I've not tried either myself. I personally would avoid open coil mattresses, though the Happy Beds orthopaedic Open Coil spring mattress does get good reviews.
See the full guide: 10 of the best mattresses
Here are the top 10 rated mattresses on Amazon with at least 10 reviews, at the time of searching (October 2018). From highest rated down:
- Happy Beds 3000 pocket spring aloe vera mattress (£370 pocket spring and memory foam mattress) - 4.8 stars
- Happy Beds Ocean Gel (£190 memory foam mattress) - 4.7 stars
- Happy Beds orthopaedic Open Coil spring mattress (£200 open coil mattress) - 4.5 stars
- Rest Assured Brodsworth Memory 2000 (£500 mattress combining 2000 pocket springs with memory foam) - 4.5 stars
- Rest Assured Houghton 1400 (£600 pocket sprung mattress) - 4.5 stars
- Nature's Sleep UK Handcrafted Luxury Gel Memory Foam Mattress (£600 memory foam mattress) - 4.5 stars
- Silentnight Stratus 1400 (£350 pocket spring mattress) - 4.5 stars
- Casper (£700 memory foam mattress) - 4.4 stars
- Happy Beds Memory Maestro (£180 open coil mattress) - 4.4 stars
- Silentnight 2000 Stratus Premier (£500 pocket spring mattress) - 4.4 stars
Prices are for King Size mattresses. We just searched for mattresses sold direct by Amazon rather than Marketplace sellers.
My best value picks from the top Amazon mattresses is the Happy Beds 3000 pocket spring aloe vera mattress which is £370 or for a cheap memory foam mattress I'd go for the Happy Beds Ocean Gel which is about £200
Both have specifications similar to mattresses for twice that price from better known brands. Both get great reviews, although I've not tried either myself. I personally would avoid open coil mattresses, though the Happy Beds orthopaedic Open Coil spring mattress does get good reviews.
See the full guide: 10 of the best mattresses
I'm a newbie to this, what's the difference between memory foam, pocket spring and latex mattresses?
Take a deep breath, it’s not actually as complicated as some people make out.
There are lots of types of mattresses but only three that I would personally considerif you are looking for the best mattress on the market:
Of course, there are other types of mattress, but open coil springs and continuous spring mattresses feel cheaper and wobblier than pocket springs. Polyurethane foam mattresses feel like you are sleeping on your grandma's sofa.
Personally, I like pocket spring mattresses because I don't like the sinking feeling of memory foam and I'm prone to getting hot in bed, but there are clearly lots of strong argument for memory foam and latex. Just to confuse you, there are also lots of mattresses which offer a combination of latex, pocket springs and memory foam.
See the full guide to memory foam v pocket springs
There are lots of types of mattresses but only three that I would personally considerif you are looking for the best mattress on the market:
- Pocket spring mattresses are the biggest sellers. They offer good consistent support and they feel familiar, but they are heavy, they collect dust and they aren't great for allergies.
- Memory foam mattresses offer great support all over. They often outlive a pocket sprung mattress and they don't cause allergies. They are also lighter for transporting and are ideal if you've got a flimsy slatted bed base. However, some people find memory foam too hot and don't like the odd sinking feeling. Cheap memory foam can smell a bit artificial.
- Latex mattresses often get rave reviews, but only if you're willing to cough up for a proper natural one. They are heavy, but they offer good support, last a long time and are good for allergies. Some find them hot, but less so than memory foam.
Of course, there are other types of mattress, but open coil springs and continuous spring mattresses feel cheaper and wobblier than pocket springs. Polyurethane foam mattresses feel like you are sleeping on your grandma's sofa.
Personally, I like pocket spring mattresses because I don't like the sinking feeling of memory foam and I'm prone to getting hot in bed, but there are clearly lots of strong argument for memory foam and latex. Just to confuse you, there are also lots of mattresses which offer a combination of latex, pocket springs and memory foam.
See the full guide to memory foam v pocket springs
What about those big name bed companies - do they make the best mattresses?
It's worth realising that a dozen of the best-known mattress brands are made by just a couple of companies.
For example, Silentnight, Layezee, Sealy, Pocket Spring Bed Company and Rest Assured are all made by Silentnight group - the UK's biggest bed manufacturer apparently.
Some bed experts argue that there will be big similarities between the different brands being made by the same company, whilst Silentnight say there is a big range in the quality of their products:
Of course, there are many other brands - but it's a similar story elsewhere with a few companies owning several brands and the shopper being left with hundreds of choices.
For example, Silentnight, Layezee, Sealy, Pocket Spring Bed Company and Rest Assured are all made by Silentnight group - the UK's biggest bed manufacturer apparently.
Some bed experts argue that there will be big similarities between the different brands being made by the same company, whilst Silentnight say there is a big range in the quality of their products:
- Pocket Spring Bed Company is the best quality from their range (they call it 'premium')
- Sealy is their second best quality.
- Silentnight and Rest Assured are next best and are a similar quality to each other.
- Layezee is the cheapest and lowest quality.
Of course, there are many other brands - but it's a similar story elsewhere with a few companies owning several brands and the shopper being left with hundreds of choices.
So, which brand of mattress would you buy?
If I had the money I'd buy a Hypnos, Vispring or Dunlopillo bed, but I haven't yet found a mid-priced brand that everyone agrees is the best mattress brand all the time.
Several newer names have appeared on the market recently offering just one or two mattresses (e.g. Leesa, Casper, Simba). They've all picked up various awards and rave reviews (and offer free trials or free exchanges) but they don't have the heritage of bigger brands.
Expert reviews are useful but you often find that brands have some mattresses which score well and others which perform poorly.
Confused?
My advice on a mid-range budget (£300 - £1000 for a king size) is to look at the construction of the bed, rather than who made it.
Several newer names have appeared on the market recently offering just one or two mattresses (e.g. Leesa, Casper, Simba). They've all picked up various awards and rave reviews (and offer free trials or free exchanges) but they don't have the heritage of bigger brands.
Expert reviews are useful but you often find that brands have some mattresses which score well and others which perform poorly.
Confused?
My advice on a mid-range budget (£300 - £1000 for a king size) is to look at the construction of the bed, rather than who made it.
I want a pocket sprung mattress - how do I spot the best mattress in the shop?
You'll find many opinions online, but after reading every mattress guide I could find, my 8 conclusions are:
1. Ignore the 'original price' - these are often inflated to make you feel you are getting a bargain.
2. Pocket sprung mattresses are better than open coil or continuous spring mattresses.
3. If you are light, 1000 springs is enough - if you are heavy then 2000 springs is better. Anything above 2000 springs is a bit pointless and showy.
1. Ignore the 'original price' - these are often inflated to make you feel you are getting a bargain.
2. Pocket sprung mattresses are better than open coil or continuous spring mattresses.
3. If you are light, 1000 springs is enough - if you are heavy then 2000 springs is better. Anything above 2000 springs is a bit pointless and showy.
|
4. The best mattresses are usually double sided. You have to flip them over regularly but a one-sided mattress is often just cheap. Some mattresses have a topper which means they can't be flipped.
5. The most supportive mattresses have 'hand side stitching' whilst cheaper mattresses have 'machine side stitching'. It's a bit complex, but if it's not written in the description and you are buying in a store, try sitting on the edge - cheap mattresses bulge more at the side. 6. The majority of top quality mattresses have a 'hand tufted' finish rather than a 'quilted' finish. That means they have buttons or something similar to keep everything in place rather than appearing completely flat. |
|
7. There are loads of different mattress fabric materials. Avoid stitchbond which is cheap and rough and is used on rubbish budget mattresses. Most people say that a woven material like damask or cotton is best on a mattress.
8. If you're buying a divan as well as a mattress, take a look at the wheels. Cheap beds come with flimsy wheels, the best bed in the shop will have decent castors.
See the full guide: 6 tips for buying the best pocket spring mattress
8. If you're buying a divan as well as a mattress, take a look at the wheels. Cheap beds come with flimsy wheels, the best bed in the shop will have decent castors.
See the full guide: 6 tips for buying the best pocket spring mattress
I want a memory foam mattress - how do I spot the best mattress in the shop?
Some guides to memory foam mattresses are so long and technical that they feel like an academic textbook.
From what I can tell, there are four things to look for if you want the best memory foam mattress in the shop.
1. Total mattress thickness ranges from about 15cm for the cheapest memory foam mattresses up about 35cm for the most expensive and best mattresses. Thicker mattresses are harder to move though.
2. Thickness of the top layer is important. The best quality foam goes on top with cheaper layers underneath. Cheap memory foam mattresses have just 1.5cm memory foam on top whilst the best mattresses have up to 15cm of memory foam. You don't need 15cm but I'd avoid those with tiny layer of memory foam if you can.
3 Covers on the best memory foam mattresses are made from something breathable like cotton, rather than polyester.
4. Density in the UK memory foam market ranges from about 35kg/m3 to 85kg/m3. It's a bit complex, but broadly speaking the best mattresses have higher density ratings. Most people say that 50kg/m3 - 60kg/m3 is perfectly good enough.
The other scores you will see are a firmness rating and an 'ILD' both of which refer to how the mattress feels, rather than how good quality it is.
There's no industry standard for firmness, but ILD (Indentation Load Deflection, if you care...) will tell you how much it sinks. Your best bet is to try a few out in a mattress shop to work out which score you prefer. Most people go for somewhere between 10 and 14 (10 feels softer than 14).
See the full guide: 5 tips for buying the best memory foam mattresses
From what I can tell, there are four things to look for if you want the best memory foam mattress in the shop.
1. Total mattress thickness ranges from about 15cm for the cheapest memory foam mattresses up about 35cm for the most expensive and best mattresses. Thicker mattresses are harder to move though.
2. Thickness of the top layer is important. The best quality foam goes on top with cheaper layers underneath. Cheap memory foam mattresses have just 1.5cm memory foam on top whilst the best mattresses have up to 15cm of memory foam. You don't need 15cm but I'd avoid those with tiny layer of memory foam if you can.
3 Covers on the best memory foam mattresses are made from something breathable like cotton, rather than polyester.
4. Density in the UK memory foam market ranges from about 35kg/m3 to 85kg/m3. It's a bit complex, but broadly speaking the best mattresses have higher density ratings. Most people say that 50kg/m3 - 60kg/m3 is perfectly good enough.
The other scores you will see are a firmness rating and an 'ILD' both of which refer to how the mattress feels, rather than how good quality it is.
There's no industry standard for firmness, but ILD (Indentation Load Deflection, if you care...) will tell you how much it sinks. Your best bet is to try a few out in a mattress shop to work out which score you prefer. Most people go for somewhere between 10 and 14 (10 feels softer than 14).
See the full guide: 5 tips for buying the best memory foam mattresses
So how much should I spend on a mattress?
It obviously depends on what your budget is, but I reckon you can get a good-enough quality king size mattress for somewhere between £250 and £1200. Of course it’s a subjective thing, but if you take a look at our guide to 10 of the best mattress retailers online you'll find you can pick up a cheap pocket spring king size mattress with 1000 springs for around £250 (Bedstar was £245 when I checked).
I wouldn't want a pocket sprung mattress with less than 1000 springs, and if you are heavier than average then you would benefit from upgrading to a few more springs.
It's obviously more if you want a base, such as a divan.
My view is that the cheapest sprung mattresses often feel very cheap (either lumpy or unsupportive), whilst the most expensive mattresses offer diminishing returns for your investment. I’m not saying that top priced mattresses aren’t better, but it’s a bit like top end hi-fi equipment – spending £3000 on a hifi won’t necessarily get you something which is three times as good as a £1000 hifi. Just my view, I’m sure others with more expertise of the industry will disagree.
This is important – don’t pay much attention to hugely inflated advertised prices for mattresses. It’s often a marketing tactic to make you feel you are a getting a bargain. A mattress which is apparently ‘reduced’ from £2500 to £1000 is often a similar quality to other mattresses on sale at £1000.
Very broadly, you’ll find that prices for a king size mattress are roughly:
Yes, I know that's a huge range...
I wouldn't want a pocket sprung mattress with less than 1000 springs, and if you are heavier than average then you would benefit from upgrading to a few more springs.
It's obviously more if you want a base, such as a divan.
My view is that the cheapest sprung mattresses often feel very cheap (either lumpy or unsupportive), whilst the most expensive mattresses offer diminishing returns for your investment. I’m not saying that top priced mattresses aren’t better, but it’s a bit like top end hi-fi equipment – spending £3000 on a hifi won’t necessarily get you something which is three times as good as a £1000 hifi. Just my view, I’m sure others with more expertise of the industry will disagree.
This is important – don’t pay much attention to hugely inflated advertised prices for mattresses. It’s often a marketing tactic to make you feel you are a getting a bargain. A mattress which is apparently ‘reduced’ from £2500 to £1000 is often a similar quality to other mattresses on sale at £1000.
Very broadly, you’ll find that prices for a king size mattress are roughly:
- £250 - £2500 for a pocket sprung mattress
- £200 - £2500 for a memory foam mattress
- £300 - £2500 for a latex mattress
Yes, I know that's a huge range...
What about firmness? How firm are the best mattresses?
Firmness is more of what is best for your build rather than a question of quality. My advice is to try out a few mattresses in a shop and see which provide you with the best support. You want to find a bed which supports you sufficiently so that your spine is straight when you lie on your side. As a general rule, heavier people need firmer beds, lighter people need softer beds (see our guide to the best beds for people with back pain).
Unfortunately there's no industry standard and so there is variation between brands of what they consider firm – a bit like a size 12 pair of trousers being three different sizes in three different clothes stores.
If you end up buying online (which generally offers the best prices) then it’s a bit of a gamble but many offer free returns if you don’t like the feel of the mattress.
Unfortunately there's no industry standard and so there is variation between brands of what they consider firm – a bit like a size 12 pair of trousers being three different sizes in three different clothes stores.
If you end up buying online (which generally offers the best prices) then it’s a bit of a gamble but many offer free returns if you don’t like the feel of the mattress.
Which is best mattress for back pain?
Does your mattress lead you to this?
Most guides I've read say that there isn't a perfect bed for a bad back, as it needs to be more individual.
That's a rather annoying thing to say when you just want someone to point you in the right direction as you wade through a choice of a thousand mattresses.
The advice I've picked up from reading many, many guides is that:
So, my advice would be to look at our guide to 10 of the best mattresses and consider the firmer ones if you are an 18 stone rugby player and the softer ones if you are a 7 stone ballerina. Or a medium one if you are somewhere in between...
Read the full guide to the best mattress for back pain and bad backs
That's a rather annoying thing to say when you just want someone to point you in the right direction as you wade through a choice of a thousand mattresses.
The advice I've picked up from reading many, many guides is that:
- Mattresses should be 'supportive' rather than just firm to help your back (the British Chiropractic Association say this amongst others)
- You need to find a mattress that supports your body so that you end up with a straight spine which is parallel to the bed (again, this is advice from the British Chiropractic Association amongst others). If you have a very specific back condition, it is more complex, but this seems to be the consensus if you are just trying to look after your back.
- A firm pocket sprung bed tends to create a nice straight spine for a very heavy person, whereas a softer bed will be better for a light person. It's not possible to say that (for example) a 10 stone person needs a medium firmness mattress, as there's no industry standard for what 'medium' actually means unfortunately. However, if you're an 'average' sized person, I'd start by looking at the medium firmness mattresses.
- If you are sharing a bed with someone twice your size then you'd be best to get a zip and link bed, which is two singles stuck together.
- Trialing a mattress is ideal. Of course, lots of us would be too embarrassed to return a mattress that wasn't faulty, but if you're less British than me, then Tempur offer a 100 night trial (£2000 mattresses). Leesa, Otty and Casper all offer 100 night trials.
- 'Orthopedic' mattresses are just a fancy term for a very firm mattress. There's nothing to say it will be better for your back. If you don't weigh much, it will probably not be great for your back.
- Lots of people recommend good quality memory foam mattresses for creating a good supportive posture for your back, such as this guide. Some of the recommendations come from memory foam sellers, but others are more independent. If you don't mind the feel of memory foam, then it's worth considering.
- High quality latex beds (such as Dunlopillo) are also given the thumbs up for being supportive (various guides, including this one). Watch out for cheap beds with a thin latex layer on top which aren't quite the same thing.
So, my advice would be to look at our guide to 10 of the best mattresses and consider the firmer ones if you are an 18 stone rugby player and the softer ones if you are a 7 stone ballerina. Or a medium one if you are somewhere in between...
Read the full guide to the best mattress for back pain and bad backs
Which type of bed base is best?
Here's another area of bed shopping where you'll find yourself scratching your head, with many sellers doing their best to confuse you for some reason...
It's actually relatively simple:
See the full guide: divan beds v bedsteads and bedframes - which is best?
It's actually relatively simple:
- Divan beds are the most popular option. They are cheap, but some people don't like the look of them as they are probably what your grandma has. A cheap divan is called a 'platform top divan base' - it's basically a box covered in fabric. A more expensive divan is called a 'sprung edge divan base' which has a layer of springs on the top, making it feel more comfortable. You can usually get drawers in a divan base if you want to pay a bit more.
- Bedsteads are the main alternative to divans. They are sometimes called bed frames, and they are usually wooden or metal, or they might have a leather type finish. Most people prefer the look of a bedstead, they allow air to flow and they come with a headboard included. They are usually more expensive than a cheap divan base. The main problem with bedsteads is that they have a slatted base (a row of wood or metal struts to support the mattress) so they don't offer the same consistent support to the mattress. The general consensus seems to be that they aren't great for pocket sprung mattresses and can make them wear out quicker, particularly if you have large gaps between the struts. You can remedy it by either getting a non-turn mattress or by filling in the gaps with your own wood (although one guide said that you should have keep gaps to help air flow). There is contradictory advice online about using memory foam mattresses with a slatted base, but my conclusion is that it's less of an issue than it is with springs particularly if you don't have big gaps between struts.
See the full guide: divan beds v bedsteads and bedframes - which is best?
What about mattress toppers?
A mattress topper is a low-cost way to add a bit of comfort to a creaky old mattress or to make it more hygienic if you've suddenly realised that it contains 30 years of sweat and is mostly held together with dust.
Cheap mattress toppers start at about £20 and are made from synthetic materials. From about £50 upwards you can get a better one with some natural fibres, such as wool, goose or duck down and feathers. The best and most expensive toppers cost as much as some new mattresses (£300+).
Alternatively, you can get a memory foam mattress topper which has a different feel altogether and which is good for allergies. Latex mattress toppers are also good, but are less common and more expensive.
There's a good selection of mattress toppers at John Lewis & Partners, Amazon and Very amongst other places.
Read the full guide to mattress toppers (honestly, it's thrilling stuff...)
Cheap mattress toppers start at about £20 and are made from synthetic materials. From about £50 upwards you can get a better one with some natural fibres, such as wool, goose or duck down and feathers. The best and most expensive toppers cost as much as some new mattresses (£300+).
Alternatively, you can get a memory foam mattress topper which has a different feel altogether and which is good for allergies. Latex mattress toppers are also good, but are less common and more expensive.
There's a good selection of mattress toppers at John Lewis & Partners, Amazon and Very amongst other places.
Read the full guide to mattress toppers (honestly, it's thrilling stuff...)
